I recently completed Bologan's Caro-Kann: A Modern Repertoire for Black (New In Chess, 2018) by GM Victor Bologan; sample pages containing the variation choices can be found at the above link. As is normally the case with repertoire books, it doesn't fully match up with my personal choices of opening variations, but I found it quite useful for new insights into general position-types, as well as fleshing out certain parts of my Caro-Kann repertoire. It is worth mentioning that this is not a "pure" repertoire book, as he does offer multiple choices for Black responses fairly frequently.
My main intention was to focus on typical plans and how to play the position-types reached, which was at least partially satisfied. Bologan is a Caro-Kann tournament player himself and this comes through in his comments and choices based on experience, not just pure analysis. As with any reference work, reviewing the lines using an up-to-date games database and engine in your own opening repertoire database is still necessary. This also makes the learning process an engaging one, rather than simply accepting the author's judgments on everything. It also helps to stimulate your own thinking and allows you to make your own personal choices, based on what you can understand in a position and is best suited for your style of play.
Here are some comments on his treatment of different parts of the Caro-Kann, from the point of view of an improving player:
Part I - Minor Lines:
- This was the first treatment of 2. Ne2 that I had seen, so it was enlightening to examine the ideas involved. Essentially Black treats it very similarly as the Advance Variation with 3...c5, but has to watch out for different ideas involving Ne2-d4, as well as Ne2-g3. On the other hand, the white knight's absence from f3 helps Black target the advanced e-pawn. Black has to be careful to not be too aggressive, but is fine in all variations.
- Bologan has the most detailed treatment of the King's Indian Attack (KIA) that I've seen, with detailed recommended lines against different White choices, including earlier (move 5) than normal. In some cases he provides useful explanations and insights into his repertoire choices for Black; in others, not so much. This is generally the case throughout the book. For example, I would have liked more discussion about a locked vs. mobile center, and the question for Black about when and where to develop the light-square bishop.
- There is no discussion about the White setup with Nf3 and d2-d3, which can be reached in the typical KIA move-order after 3. Nf3. This is likely due to the fact it did not become more popular until after the book was released.
- For the Fantasy Variation, Bologan recommends the solid 3...e6, which I don't play. His treatment of it seems comprehensive, though.
- The Two Knights Variation is included in this section and he shows the lines with 3...Bg4, which are reliable for Black.
- Although these are treated as "minor" lines, Bologan presents them in more depth than introductory books and the preparation he shows will be valuable for Black at the Class level, where especially the Fantasy, Two Knights and KIA are all relatively popular.
- I don't play his recommendations for the first two variations, but I found his analysis of the Exchange Variation again to be the best for Black that I have encountered. This is important, given it is certainly popular at the Class level - I've personally encountered it recently - and seems to have had at least a minor resurgence in master games.
- This part was a mixed bag for me, as there are a number of sidelines in the so-called Main Line Classical (4...Bf5). Most of his recommendations up to move 7 were very useful for me, and he treats in-depth the setups involving 6. N1e2 and 6. Bc4, as well as seriously examining the early f2-f4 ideas for White on moves 6 and 7, which is often under-analyzed or not treated in Caro-Kann references.
- I don't play the standard main line starting from move 8, and Bologan seems to like castling queenside versus kingside for Black, which is not my preference.
- I don't play this.
- Bologan at the end presents 40 positions drawn from tournament (including ICCF) play, for solving from both the White and Black perspectives. I found this useful for boosting pattern recognition of typical tactical and positional ideas in the Caro-Kann, including situations with opposite-side castling, ideas of undermining of White's center with pawn breaks (...b5, ...c5 and ...f6) and identifying vulnerabilities allowing White to sacrifice successfully on e6 or g6/h6.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Your comments and ideas on chess training and this site are welcomed.
Please note that moderation is turned on as an anti-spam measure; your comment will be published as soon as possible, if it is not spam.